Head to Head: EQ Printables vs. Jacquard Cotton Sheets

I’ve been doing some printing on fabric off and on lately, using EQ Printables Premium Cotton Satin Inkjet Fabric Sheets. I picked up a 6 sheet package at Quilt Market in Houston in 2008 so that I could try it out. The results with the EQ Printables are okay, but I haven’t been ecstatically happy with them, so when I was ordering from SoftExpressions.com recently, I decided to order a package of Jacquard Cotton Ink Jet Printing Sheets to see if it was any better.

I actually wasn’t planning on doing any sort of really scientific side-by-side comparison when I ordered the Jacquard, but after I printed an image on the EQ Printables and was pretty unhappy with the way the ink ran and spread during the rinsing phase, I decided to print the same image on the Jacquard to test it out. And okay, it’s still not a terribly thorough analysis since it’s not like I’m going to burn through three or four more sheets to test different kinds of images on each of these brands, but I think the results are worth sharing anyway.

Here’s the head to head, brutal comparison:
Jacquard cotton ink jet printing fabric sheetsJacquard Cotton, 10 8½x11″ sheets, MSRP $15.49 ($1.55/sheet):

Pros:

  • The fabric grain is straight on the sheets, so if you’re transferring an image with straight edges, you won’t have problems.
  • Backing paper is similar to freezer paper; thick enough to be stable, but not so thick that it hangs up in the printer.
  • Color is a nice bright white.
  • Fabric quality and thread count seem appropriate and perform well.
  • Color bleeding is very minimal.

Cons:

  • Recommended drying time of 24 hours between printing and rinsing is way too long to wait to move ahead with a project.

EQ Printables ink jet printing fabric sheetsEQ Printables Premium Cotton Satin, 6 8½x11″ sheets, MSRP $19.95 ($3.32/sheet):

Pros:

  • I like the thread count. It’s a really high 238 thread count on the Cotton Satin variety of the EQ Printables and the fabric is really smooth.
  • Drying time between printing and rinsing is a mere 15 minutes, so you can get on with your project quickly.

Cons:

  • Horribly off grain. If you print something—like a photo—that you expect to have straight and square edges when finished, it won’t because the fabric is and stuck to the backing plastic off-grain, so when the fabric is removed and washed, the image will be visibly crooked when the grain straightens itself out. This might not matter for some images of course, but it’s still annoying.
  • Backing paper is plastic. It’s nice and stable, but really, plastic? Why? That’s not very green or earth friendly is it?
  • Color is rather yellowed looking, not a very bright white.
  • Reds, pinks, and purples bleed excessively when rinsed.
  • Cost, cost, cost. Expensive, comparatively speaking.

Both of the printable fabrics traveled through the printer easily and produced clear, crisp images. I’m working with fonts and very thin lines for this project, not photos, but I think this is actually a great test of these two products. The bottom line for me on this is that the red ink ran noticeably on the EQ Printables, leaving the fabric pink in the areas around the red numbers. The red ink bled only slightly on the Jacquard (I think a bit of bleeding is unavoidable with certain colors of ink), but after drying it isn’t noticeable at all.

Ink jet printables comparison, EQ Printables vs. Jacquard Cotton

You can see this in this side-by-side shot of both printed products, with the EQ Printables on the left and the Jacquard on the right. Both of the products have been printed with the same amount of ink, dried for the same amount of time, rinsed the same, pressed dry with an iron and backed with fusible web.

For my money, Jacquard Cotton Ink Jet Printing Sheets win hands down, considering bleeding issues and the fact that the cost is less than half (!) what the EQ Printables are per sheet. I’d even put up with the fabric being off grain just to have the ink stay where it’s supposed to, but thankfully I don’t have to because the Jacquard fabric doesn’t have the grain problem. The thread count is a non-issue, as the obviously lower thread count on the Jacquard brand doesn’t seem to affect the print quality even on the very thin (1 pixel) lines around the numbers. I like the fact that the Jacquard fabric is delivered on paper backing as opposed to plastic. Cheaper, less bleeding of ink and friendlier to the environment? Now THAT’s what I’m talking about! 🙂

What brands of ink jet printable fabric sheets have you tried? Why do you like or dislike them?

9 thoughts on “Head to Head: EQ Printables vs. Jacquard Cotton Sheets

  1. I totally agree with you about the Jacquard sheets. I have tried many, many brands b/c I love memory quilts. They are by far the best at holding their ink, hanging straight in the finished quilt, and being washable.

    And you are right that you cannot beat the price. I have a friend who is a wholesaler. She can’t get Jacquard, but even she can’t buy the brand she reps for the price I can order these online, or even get them at my local art supply store!

    Just a note…I guess I didn’t read the directions, but I have NEVER waited 24 hours to use mine. But then, I don’t rinse either unless there is a lot of color on it. No worries at all!

    Thanks for the side-by-side. I have always wondered about these since they are the one brand I know of that I haven’t tried.

    P.s. the silk is great too for special projects.

    Like

    1. I did wonder if waiting 24 hours was really necessary, but since I was trying to make sure I followed the instructions to the letter, I did it anyway. Nice to know it’s not as big an issue as they make it out to be!

      I haven’t done much other comparison shopping, so thanks for all your info Jen. And I do think I’ll have to get some of that silk on my next order!

      Like

  2. Hi Nadine,

    I am always confused about how to permanently set these self prints. Can you? I wash my quilts so they must be permanent. I have had good luck with Spoonflower,com but it takes a few weeks to get your print.

    Like

    1. Hi Kelly! I don’t use these printable sheets for too many projects, and actually haven’t really washed/used them enough to tell HOW permanent they will be. And mostly, I use them for things that don’t get washed much, if at all.

      The whole point though, as I understand it, is that these printable fabrics are pre-treated with chemicals that will make the printing as permanent (or nearly as permanent) as a regular printed quilting fabric. Maybe do a test with a piece and wash it weekly with your clothes for a while to see how it goes?

      Like

  3. I have used the EQ ones before to make labels with. I always heat set them. (NO I did not read the directions – a failing of mine! Anyway I have not had any problems with the color washing out or fading or bleeding. Just lucky perhaps.
    Leslie

    Like

    1. Hi Leslie! Thanks for sharing your experiences! Do you mean that you only heat set them, and don’t rinse them out before you use them in your quilt?

      Like

Comments are closed